Martha's Vineyard is not just a summer destination for pristine beaches and charming boutiques—it's also a haven for foodies with a sweet tooth. From indulgent baked goods to handcrafted ice cream, this island offers an incredible array of dessert spots you won't want to miss. Whether you're staying at one of the boutique hotels in the Edgartown Collection or just visiting for the day, here are three must-visit dessert destinations that will satisfy your cravings and leave you coming back for more.
Back Door Donuts | 1-11 Kennebec Ave., Oak Bluffs | (508) 693-3688
If you ask any local or visitor where to find the best desserts on Martha's Vineyard, Back Door Donuts will likely top their list. This legendary bakery in Oak Bluffs is famous for its late-night service, where you can grab a warm apple fritter, gooey cinnamon roll, or a classic Boston cream donut straight from the oven. The smell alone is worth the trip! Pair your treat with a cup of coffee and enjoy it under the starry Vineyard sky.
Location Tip: Staying at one of the Edgartown Collection hotels? Back Door Donuts is a short drive away and the perfect sweet stop after dinner or a sunset stroll.
Ice Cream & Candy Bazaar | 11 Dock St, Edgartown | (508) 627-8735
No visit to Martha's Vineyard is complete without a stop at Edgartown's own Ice Cream & Candy Bazaar. This family-friendly shop offers a wide selection of homemade ice creams, sorbets, and decadent sundaes. Try their Vineyard-exclusive flavors like "Beach Plum Sorbet" or "Edgartown Mud Pie" for a true taste of the island. For a nostalgic treat, check out their candy section, brimming with chocolates, gummies, and old-fashioned confections.
Pro Tip: Located right in downtown Edgartown, it's an easy stop before heading back to your boutique hotel to enjoy your treat in comfort.
Rosewater Market & Takeaway | 20 South Summer St, Edgartown | (508) 627-1270
For dessert lovers who prefer a chic, artisanal twist, Rosewater Market in Edgartown is a must-visit. Known for their delectable pies, brownies, and cookies, this stylish market sources local ingredients to craft desserts that are as beautiful as they are delicious. Don't miss their seasonal fruit tarts or their signature chocolate chip cookie—perfect for pairing with a glass of chilled milk.
Why It's Special: Conveniently located near the Edgartown Collection hotels, Rosewater Market is a quick walk for guests who want to savor the island's sweetest offerings without straying too far.