Edgartown has the most dining options on Martha's Vineyard, so it can be tough to narrow down your options during your stay. From seafood overlooking the water to inventive farm-to-table fare, Edgartown has a restaurant serving whatever you're in the mood for. Edgartown, nestled on the picturesque island of Martha's Vineyard, is home to some of the most memorable dining experiences New England has to offer. Guests of the Edgartown Collection boutique hotels are always asking for the best places to dine, and we're here to deliver. Below are must-visit restaurants for an unforgettable dinner in Edgartown.
Atlantic | 2 Main Street, Edgartown | (508) 627-7001
This fish and chop house masters the classics, from prime steaks and steamed lobster to swordfish steaks and king crab legs. But it also has inventive salads and starters, using fresh produce and drawing influence from around the world. Its waterfront location and nautical vibe will make dinner at Atlantic a memorable night out in Edgartown.
Go local with the farm-to-table menu at:
Atria | 137 Main Street, Edgartown | (508) 627-5850
This elegant farmhouse restaurant has an upscale option and a more casual one downstairs. The inventive menu marries local produce and seafood with global inspiration. Try Point Judith calamari to start or in-season heirloom tomatoes with burrata, then enjoy one of the creative entrees, like prosciutto-wrapped cod with carrot-ginger puree. Wine lovers will be in heaven here, with the great selection of rare California wines.
Chesca's | 38 N Water St, Edgartown | (508) 627-1234
For a romantic evening or a special family dinner, Chesca's Restaurant delivers an elegant dining experience in the heart of Edgartown. The menu features a thoughtful mix of classic Italian dishes and fresh New England seafood. Pair their signature Lobster Risotto with a fine wine from their curated list, and you've got the perfect Vineyard evening.
In the mood for fresh seafood and cocktails? Visit:
The Port Hunter | 55 Main Street, Edgartown | (508) 627-7747
The Port Hunter captures the essence of Edgartown with its vibrant atmosphere and commitment to serving fresh, locally-sourced ingredients. Known for its lively vibe, this restaurant offers a menu that celebrates coastal cuisine with a creative twist. From perfectly shucked oysters to hearty entrees like pan-seared halibut, every dish is a testament to the island's bounty. Don't miss unique dishes like lobster rangoon and fried oyster steam buns to start the meal along with the bar's great specialty cocktail program. A casual but hip vibe makes this one of our top dinner recommendations in Edgartown.