There's a lot of opinions on who has the best lobster rolls on Martha's Vineyard, and we're here to add ours to the mix. Our guests frequently ask "where do I go for the best lobster rolls in Edgartown?", and after eating around the island, we can confidently recommend these three as some of the best. Seafood lovers will want to get their fill of fresh New England lobster while visiting the Vineyard, so next time you're on a lark to Martha's Vineyard, visit these restaurants for the best lobster rolls in Edgartown.
Square Rigger | 225 Edgartown-Vineyard Haven Rd, Edgartown | (508) 627-9968
A longtime favorite among locals and visitors alike, Square Rigger Restaurant serves up one of the best lobster rolls in Edgartown. Located in a charming former sea captain’s home, this cozy spot offers a lobster roll brimming with fresh, juicy lobster meat, lightly dressed and served on a perfectly toasted bun. Pair it with a side of their crispy fries and a refreshing glass of wine for a meal that captures the true essence of New England dining. Stop by for lunch or dinner and savor this iconic dish in an inviting, relaxed atmosphere.
The Seafood Shanty | 31 Dock St., Edgartown | (508) 627-8622
Claiming to have the biggest lobster roll in Edgartown, The Seafood Shanty's version weighs in at 6.5 ounces of lobster meat. Lightly dressed with mayonnaise and some chopped celery for crunch, we love the lobster roll at the Shanty. Enjoy a seat on the patio of this harborfront restaurant and watch the ferry to Chappy come and go while you enjoy your meal. Pair it with a glass of chilled rosé and soak in the harbor breeze from their rooftop deck.
Harbor View Hotel | 131 N Water St, Edgartown | (508) 627-3761
For a lobster roll experience with stunning harbor views, head to the Harbor View Hotel in Edgartown. Their on-site restaurant, Bettini, offers a refined take on this New England classic, featuring succulent chunks of fresh lobster dressed in a light citrus aioli and served on a buttery brioche roll. Enjoy it alongside a crisp glass of rosé while soaking in the breathtaking waterfront setting. Perfect for lunch or dinner, Harbor View Hotel combines gourmet flavors with quintessential Vineyard charm, making it a must-visit for lobster roll enthusiasts.